DTV Over-the-Air Antenna System Design
Patrick Ziegler Wholesale Electronics Inc.
The advent of DTV has left antenna installers in fringe areas sometimes scratching their heads.
We welcome any RF engineers or subject matter experts to share your thoughts on this subject by emailing us at info@weisd.com
In the past antenna system design was a pretty straight forward procedure. Estimate or measure the field strength of the transmitting stations, choose an appropriate antenna or antennas, calculate your losses in the down lead and choose an appropriate preamplifier to compensate.
If you needed a distribution system, you designed that and picked the appropriate distribution amplifier to maintain adequate signal strength to all receivers on the system.
DTV problem #1: Because of the nature of the DTV signal, you cannot measure the field strength of the transmitting station. So, you have to make the assumption that your favorite station is providing similar service as they did with analog TV.
Some stations have migrated away from their old frequencies. Others, who were previously transmitting DTV on temporary frequencies, have moved back to their original frequencies. Some will make these changes in June of this year.
Many low-band TV frequencies, (Chnls 2 through 6) have been abandoned for fear of issues with electrical interference.
To add to the confusion, we now have both, “Virtual Channels” and "Actual Channels, normally the channel you are use to referring to your favorite station as and what appears on you DTV receiver, and “Actual Channels”, the actual bandwidth and frequency that the station is transmitting on. Many times these two are not only different but in different bands.
You may think you are watching Chnl 5 but really be tuned to Chnl.23.
The so called, “Signal Level Meter” imbedded in most digital TV's and Digital Converter boxes is really not a “Level” meter but a measure of signal quality or readability. It is possible to have good signal level and poor signal quality. In analog we had, "Signal to Noise" ratio in the DTV world we have, "Bit Error Rate" or BER. Noise, interference and ghosting, (multipath interference) cause "bits" of data to be lost. When enough data is lost your receiver simply stops showing you the video stream.
DTV problem #2: Trouble shooting receiver problems with analog signals was very easy. Your receiver showed you the trouble. If you had a lot of noise in the picture that meant you had either no signal at the antenna or you where losing too much via the down lead or distribution system.
Multipath, skip and other atmospheric issues were evident in the picture..
With DTV, you cannot see these issues. They do not manifest themselves in the picture at all. The picture simply goes away or becomes too intermittent to watch.
People who live in out lying areas have become accustomed to watching less than perfect reception. Snowy pictures, multipath and electrical interference are things that people learned to live with. With DTV, these issues cause complete loss of the picture.
DTV Problem number 3: Digital TV's and Digital to Analog converters do not tune on the fly, as did analog TV's.
If you make changes to the antenna system or if the transmitting station has changed, you need to rescan the channels with your TV or converter box.
This is important if your antenna system includes a rotator. After turning your antenna, you will need to rescan.
So, What can we do?
From the output of the receiving antenna down, we can still go about things the old-fashion way. We can determine the highest frequency on our down lead, (using the “Real Channel”) and use this to calculate our cable loss and choose the appropriate preamplifier to compensate. We can do the same for our distribution system.
Calculating Cable Loss:
I think a good rule of thumb to use here is, (UHF –6dB/100') & (VHF –3dB/100ft). However you can look at the exact numbers for your particular cable on the manufacturer's data sheet.
For any hardware on the line add –1dB insertion loss plus whatever loss or gain that device may have at the frequency of the receive signal.
Add up all your losses and then choose a preamplifier to offset these losses.

Choosing the Antenna:
As a former Broadcast Engineer this is where things begin to depart from the old for me. It used to be easy to estimate what one could expect for field strength at the receiving end using propagation models and any free online service such as tvfool.com
Now we really have no numbers to work with. Signal strength and signal-to-noise ratio are impossible to measure with DTV today.
At this point, the best we can do using what we already know about antennas and TV reception and what we have learned about DTV reception is make an educated guess.
Metro Areas:
It is possible to have too much signal. If you are located close to a transmitting tower, you may need to attenuate these near stations. Overdriving the front end of a receiver creates noise; DTV and noise are a bad combination.
Multi Path in metro areas can also lead to issues. DTV receivers will not tolerate a strong Multi Path signal.
Rural and Deep Fringe areas:
Multi path is a problem here also as in metro areas as well as low signal. These with the addition of any other interference can result in a “Bit Error Rate” that your receiver will find unacceptable.
High-Gain Directional antennas and stacked antenna arrays can help. The more directional the antenna the less susceptible it is to ghosting (Multi Path) and the higher gain will give you more signal strength.
Vertically stacked antennas need to be ½ wavelength of the lowest receive frequency apart on the mast and the interconnect cables need to be exactly the same length. This allows the signal from both antennas to add together in the combiner.
Two vertically stacked antennas will give you near +3dB of gain over a single antenna.

Transmitting Stations in Multiple Directions:
In many rural areas you may find yourself between transmitting stations. You might have stations located in two or three different directions.
In this event, you may need to install two or three different antennas orientated in different directions.
Or, you might want to install a rotator to rotate a single antenna. The trouble here is, every time you rotate your antenna, you will need to re scan the channels with your TV or converter box.
A multiple antenna system might be a better alternative.
However, multiple antennas on the same down lead can lead to multi-path or ghosting issues.
To minimize this, antenna spacing is critical. Space antennas no less than 1/2 wavelength apart using the lowest frequency on the system. It might also be necessary to install traps or filters between antennas and combiners to attenuate multi-path signals.
Band-Pass filters built for NTSC or Analog Television may be problematic when used with DTV. Band-Stop filters might work better until the industry brings DTV filters to market.

In my opinion, many viewers on the fringes have lost Free-Over-The-Air television. As said above, they have watched snowy or otherwise marginal pictures for years and grown use to it. Now, on the fringes, they have lost reception.
Some can get it back with a new re-designed antenna system and others we will just not be able to help.
The FCC has always been an advocate for free over the air TV largely because of the Emergency Broadcast Network now known as EAS.
It will be interesting once all the broadcasters have made the switch what will happen and or adjustments will be made to our new DTV transmission system.